Authentic/Inauthentic mysticism
Authentic/Inauthentic mysticism
Cl. Mario D’Couto sdb
How
do we judge whether a mystical experience is authentic or not? Given the fact
that mysticism is a wide phenomenon found in every religion practically, it is
certain that there is a wide variety of opinions as to what authentic mysticism
is. As a Christian, I would like to share what mysticism means from a Christian
standpoint.
In the Christian tradition, there
have been many scholars and doctors of the Church who have written about
mysticism. Even philosophers like (mostly Christian) have written about
mysticism. One thing common that can be
pointed out among all their writings is that it was always a pointer
towards something beyond; something beyond this physical world and thus it is
because of this that mysticism is a mystery.
The French philosopher Gabriel
Marcel would define a ‘problem’ and a ‘mystery’ in the following way, “A problem is something that can be solved
while a mystery is something that cannot be solved and while we may not have
all the answers to all the mysteries, nevertheless, we are called to live with
it.” Life is in itself a mystery.
Mysticism, in the Christian
understanding, is not so much about our love for Jesus but Jesus’ love for us. It
is about God being the core of our being and the core of all beings. Yet, all
the same, in as much as mysticism is about union with God, it is and should
never be done in isolation. To enter into the mystery of Christ is not to
escape from the world. It is centred on the mystery of the Cross. This means
that it is the mystery of the poor, the sick, the afflicted, the deranged, the
imprisoned, the dying and all those suffering in various other ways. It is the
mystery of the exploited, the manipulated, the terrorized, and the oppressed. It
is the mystery of the nuclear war, of hunger, of injustice and of human
anguish. It is the mystery of you and me when we suffer and when we sin.
Christian mystical experience, far from fleeing from the suffering and sinful
world, is an entrance into its very heart.
Mystical experience is not about
some ‘spiritual high’ which gives one a blissful feeling. Of course, we may
feel that way but if it has not pushed us towards God and towards our
neighbour, then his or her mystical experience is no better than a drug –
induced state. This is an important indication to check whether one’s mystical
experience is truly authentic or not.